11.9 C
London
Thursday, April 23, 2026

Woman left confined to wheelchair by mum testing new SUV

A mother-of-seven left a woman confined to a wheelchair after she accidentally ploughed a brand new SUV into her while testing it on the forecourt of a car dealership.

Mature student Hayat Ibrhim, 36, had been having trouble driving her £40,000 Nissan X-Trail so she asked a salesman to show her how to use the controls.

But as the staff member helped her work the pedals and brake, Ibrhim mistakenly put her foot on the accelerator, a court heard.

The SUV – weighing almost two tons – shot forwards, colliding into the back of Karen Smaali, who was herself purchasing a new vehicle.

The 55-year-old – who was due to undergo a hip operation due to mobility problems  – had been hoping the purchase would give her more independence.

Instead she sustained severe head and leg injuries in the 30mph impact at Lookers Nissan in Chester and was left in a coma for ten days.

During her stay in hospital the mother-of-three developed sepsis in her left leg which had to be amputated and she also suffered a stroke. 

She is now confined to a wheelchair and will never walk again.

Hayat Ibrhim, 36, asked staff at a dealership for help using the controls of her brand-new £40,000 Nissan X-Trail but mistakenly put her foot on the accelerator, ploughing into fellow customer Karen Smaali

Karen Smaali, 55, had hoped that buying a new car was 'going to give me independence', she told a court - but instead she had a leg amputated and is now confined to a wheelchair after Hayat Ibrhim lost control of an SUV weighing nearly two tons

Mrs Smaali, an ethnic minorities housing support officer from Wrexham, relived the accident at Chester magistrates court.

Ibrhim, from Anfield, Liverpool, was sentenced to 26 weeks in custody suspended for 24 months.

She was also banned from driving for two years after she admitted causing serious injury by careless driving.

‘I had hoped buying a new car was going to give me independence,’ Mrs Smaali told the hearing. 

‘I was excited and I was going to make a day of collecting the car. I even wore new clothes. 

‘I remember the lady and her family walking into the car dealership and the next thing I felt a vehicle go into my leg.

‘My body was pushed forward and I hit my head on the boot of my car. 

‘I lost my vision and I thought there was blood pouring in my eyes.

Lookers Nissan in Chester where Karen Smaali was left confined to a wheelchair after a fellow customer accidentally ploughed her brand new SUV into her while was testing it

‘I remember hearing screaming and it took a while to realise that it was in fact me screaming. 

‘I remember someone saying “Cut her clothes” and I was angry because they were my new clothes and because at that time I had not comprehended what happened.’

Mrs Smaali said when she came round from being in a coma and was told she had lost her leg, her first thought was ‘I wish they had let me die’.

Now instead of enjoying family time and walking her dog, her life revolves around trips to hospital, she added. 

‘I can no longer walk Scooby and I feel I have lost the freedom I had in my life. 

‘All my life I have been tough but I am really struggling to come to terms with the loss of my leg and the impact will have on me for the rest of my life.’

Mrs Smaali said her sons now had to act as her carers, leaving her feeling guilty, while she is blighted by phantom pains and nightmares.

‘They often start off with something totally unrelated to the incident but always end up progressing to the collision,’ she told the court. 

‘My neighbours have stated that they have heard me screaming at night.

‘I wake up every morning thinking I still have a leg thinking the amputation was just a nightmare I am just waking up from. 

‘Whatever justice is served in the court room would not compare with what I have to cope with for the rest of my life.

‘The biggest impact is the loss of dignity.

The incident occurred on March 13 when both women were collecting their new cars. 

Lisa McGuire, prosecuting, said: ‘The defendant has trouble moving her car off and is shown how to engage the vehicle by a member of staff from Lookers.

‘He takes time to show her how to move the vehicle, but the vehicle accelerates suddenly and it strikes the victim who is standing a few metres away.

In mitigation for Ibrhim, Oliver Jarvis said his client had been driving for ten years without issue.

Accepting that everyone in court would have been ‘deeply moved’ by Mrs Smaali’s  words, he insisted that his client was ‘torn up by the injury she caused’.

He said the garage worker demonstrated ‘releasing the electronic handbrake, pressing and holding the foot brake, pressing the start engine button and then releasing the foot brake’.

‘But it is clear that she has made an error in terms of the right pedal – hence the vehicle shooting forward.

He said four of Ibrhm’s children suffer from a rare genetic disorder and her life revolves around taking and collecting the youngsters around various schools and hospital appointments.

Mr Jarvis added: ‘She takes responsibility for her actions and she does not minimise the offence in any way. 

‘She is deeply, deeply sorry.’

Ibrhm was also ordered to complete 200 hours of unpaid work and pay £239 in costs and surcharge. 

She must pass an extended driving retest before she can get her licence back.

In freeing Ibrhm, Deputy District Judge Owen Jones said he took into account her clean driving record plus the ‘devastating impact’ imprisoning her would have on her children.

‘But this was a brief incident which had catastrophic consequences resulting in life-changing injuries,’ he added. 

Hot this week

Diana’s ex-hairdresser condemns ‘evil’ comments about Kate’s hair

Princess Diana's former hairdresser has condemned 'nasty' comments made about the Princess of Wales 's hair - as she stepped out with her newly blonde tresses.

The unusual breakfast request Princess Lilibet asks Meghan Markle for

Meghan Markle revealed her children's favourite meals and that she 'doesn't like baking' on the second season of her lifestyle show With Love, Meghan.

Experts reveal how many tins of tuna is safe to eat a week

The NHS advises people to eat at least two portions of fish a week, yet a recent investigation revealed toxic metals, including mercury, could be lurking in cans of tinned tuna sold in the UK.

Some people DO see ghosts – and medics say there’s an explanation

An astonishing third of people in the UK and almost half of Americans say they believe in ghosts, spirits and other types of paranormal activity.

Prince Philip’s nickname only his nearest and dearest could call him

From 'Lillibet' to 'Grandpa Wales', members of the Royal Family are known to go by many nicknames.

Prince William and Kate mark Louis’s eighth birthday with new portrait

The previously unseen portrait of Louis was captured by Prince William and Kate's royal photographer Matt Porteous during a sitting in Cornwall earlier this month.

Rectal cancer deaths ‘surging in millennials’ – what you need to know

Amid America's colorectal cancer explosion, a new study reveals rectal cancer, in particular, is increasingly striking young adults, a new study from SUNY Upstate Medical University has found.

‘Mr Blackburn Rovers’ Tony Parkes dead aged 76: Shearer leads tributes

Parkes was a coach with the Lancashire club during their 1994-95 Premier League-winning season under Kenny Dalglish.

Lucy Letby cops make new arrest

The force said on Wednesday that officers had executed a warrant and searched the home of an unnamed individual.

Forget a facelift! This hairstyle will instantly make you look younger

Whether it's an unreasonably high price tag or the possibility of unpleasant side effects, anti-ageing hacks all too often come with a catch.

Woman abandoned by father as baby and cut from will wins £123K payout

Emma McDaniel's dad Mark Talbot walked out of her life when she was only eight months old.

Prince Harry appeals directly to Putin to ‘stop this war’ with Ukraine

After arriving in the Ukrainian capital secretly by train on Thursday morning, Harry, 41, spoke a security conference where he made a plea to Putin for peace, telling him he will never win.

Louis is the spitting image of William in new 8th birthday portrait

In celebration of Louis' eighth birthday today, Kensington Palace have released a new portrait of the young prince that bears a striking likeness to Britain's future King.
spot_img

Related Articles

Popular Categories

spot_imgspot_img