Wednesday, June 25, 2025
26.5 C
London

Starmer says crunch vote on benefits curbs WILL go ahead on Tuesday

Keir Starmer insisted a crunch Commons vote on benefits reforms will go ahead next week despite facing a disastrous defeat.

The PM is looking down the barrel of a huge rebellion with nearly 130 MPs having signed an amendment that would effectively kill off flagship legislation.

Rachel Reeves has been ringing round backbenchers warning that losing the curbs to health and disability benefits would ‘devastate’ the government. 

Even with the proposed £5billion of savings welfare costs will still be soaring, and economists believe she will have to hike taxes in the Autumn to balance the books.

The the scale of the insurrection is enough to overturn Labour’s huge majority. The last time a government Bill was lost at second reading was 1986. 

One minister has already quit in protest, with others thought to be ready to walk out.

But speaking at the Nato summit this morning, Sir Keir dismissed intense speculation in Whitehall that he could opt to delay the showdown. 

‘There’ll be a vote on Tuesday, we’re going to make sure we reform the welfare system,’ he said.

Arguing his party was elected ‘to change that which is broken’, he said the welfare system ‘doesn’t work for anyone’.

He added: ‘It traps people in a position where they can’t get into work. In fact, it’s counterproductive, it works against them getting into work.

‘So we have to reform it, and that is a Labour argument, it’s a progressive argument.’

Standing in for Sir Keir at PMQs, Angela Rayner reiterated that the vote will happen. ‘We will go ahead on Tuesday,’ she said. 

Keir Starmer faces delaying his flagship benefits reforms to avert a disastrous Commons defeat amid a mounting revolt

Standing in for Sir Keir at PMQs, Angela Rayner reiterated that the vote will happen. 'We will go ahead on Tuesday,' she said

The revolt has continued to build, with more Labour MPs adding their names to the amendment overnight

Rachel Reeves has been ringing round backbenchers warning that losing the curbs to health and disability benefits would 'devastate' the government

In the Commons shadow chancellor Mel Stride warned that ‘tax rises are coming’ in this Autumn’s budget, with the number of benefits claimants set to rise. 

But Ms Rayner vowed not to ‘walk away and stand by and abandon millions of people trapped in the failing system left behind by him and his colleagues’.

Earlier, social security minister Sir Stephen Timms told MPs today there was ‘urgency’ in the need for reform to the welfare system.

Work and Pensions Committee chairwoman Debbie Abrahams, who is one of the Labour MPs to have signed the amendment to block the legislation, asked why the provisions within the Bill had not been consulted on.

‘Essentially because of the urgency of the changes needing to be made,’ he replied. 

‘If we look at personal independence payment (Pip) – the year before the pandemic, in current prices, Pip cost the then government £12 billion. Last year it cost the government £22 billion and the cost of it went up by £3 billion per year – or £2.8 billion per year – last year alone.

‘And that is not a sustainable trajectory. So there was a need for urgency with the changes.’

But, pressed by Ms Abrahams, he accepted that rise in cost of living is also a factor because ‘people who may well have always been eligible but have not in the past claimed benefit, are now doing’.

The rebellion against changes to Universal Credit and Personal Independence Payments (Pip) extends far beyond the ‘usual suspects’ on Labour’s hard Left.

The list includes former Cabinet minister Louise Haigh, ex-whip Vicky Foxcroft, who quit her government job over the issue last week, and a dozen select committee chairmen.

Social Security Minister Sir Stephen Timms told MPs today there was 'urgency' in the need for reform to the welfare system.

Work and Pensions Committee chairwoman Debbie Abrahams, who is one of the Labour MPs to have signed the amendment to block the legislation, asked why the provisions within the Bill had not been consulted on.

Manchester Mayor Andy Burnham urged the leadership to think again last night

Labour whips and senior ministers including Angela Rayner and Wes Streeting were last night ringing round to persuade MPs to change their minds.

But the revolt has continued to build, with more adding their names to the amendment overnight.

Some senior Labour figures blame Downing Street and Work and Pensions Secretary Liz Kendall for allowing the debate to be framed as ‘cuts’.

‘It has been sold badly to the Parliamentary Party,’ one insider told MailOnline. ‘The message from the outset should have been that this is the only way to save the welfare system Labour created, or it might exist in a couple of decades.’ 

Manchester Mayor Andy Burnham urged the leadership to think again last night, joining London Mayor Sadiq Khan in speaking out. 

‘The Government needs to take a more unifying path… there is genuine, deep anxiety about these proposals,’ Mr Burnham told the BBC’s Newsnight.

Officials had been said to be drawing up contingency plans to delay the vote until later in the year if compromises cannot be found. 

A party source said: ‘With some, it’s a case of appealing to their party loyalty; with others it’s appealing to their ambition and making the point that anyone serious about wanting to be a minister will have to back the Government on a vote like this.

‘But the scale of it is enormous and there is not much time before the vote.’

Defeat would raise questions about whether Labour can ever tame the sickness benefits bill, which is on course to top £100billion a year by the next election if the reforms are dropped.

Kemi Badenoch has offered Tory support for the legislation, provided Sir Keir commits to further measures to bring down the bloated benefits bill and get people back to work – and guarantees no further tax rises.

However, Labour immediately dismissed the prospects of Sir Keir agreeing to such terms.

A spokesman said: ‘We’re fixing the abysmal mess the Tories left behind, and MPs can either vote to keep a broken, failed welfare system that writes people off, or they can vote to start fixing it.’

Advertisement

Hot this week

Xbox One to launch in China this month after all

Happy Sunday from Software Expand! In this week's edition...

Gadget Ogling: Amazon on Fire, Virtual Reality, True Nature and Energy Relief

Happy Sunday from Software Expand! In this week's edition...

Gabby Logan reveals major bedroom move forward has been the secret to her 23-year marriage to husband Kenny after he shared the effect his...

Gabby Logan recently revealed her secrets to a happy marriage after her husband Kenny Logan opened up...

George Baldock funeral: Dele Alli bows his head for his ‘brother’ as aged team-mates pay tribute to tragic footballer in Sheffield after he was...

The ex-Sheffield United star - who was born in England but played internationally for Greece - was...

Private schools Budget VAT raid confirmed in recent year as Rachel Reeves refuses to postpone removing tax exemption despite fears for schools and students

Private schools Budget VAT raid confirmed in recent year as Rachel Reeves refuses to postpone removing tax exemption despite fears for schools and students
Starting in the new year fee-paying schools will no longer be exempt from the tax, and will...

England vs Netherlands – U21 Euros semi-final: Live score and updates

Follow Mail Sport's live blog for the latest score, team news and updates from the U21 Euros semi-final between England and the Netherlands at the Stadion Tehelne Pole.

British tennis star Jodie Burrage left BAFFLED after bizarre incident

British tennis star Jodie Burrage was left in disbelief after losing a point in incredibly unlucky circumstances at Eastbourne on Wednesday.

Modric’s next club is revealed, as European giant confirms move

Luka Modric's next club appears to be all but confirmed, with the legendary Croatian midfielder set to join his new side on a one-season deal.

Iran strike like Hiroshima, Trump says as NATO chief calls him ‘daddy’

RECAP: Trump compared the Iran strikes to the two nuclear bombs dropped on Japan at the end of WWII, claiming his strikes also ended a war by pushing Iran to the negotiating table.

Eco-friendly food bins rollout causes ‘chaos’ as wild donkeys break in

Plastic caddies to recycle leftovers have been distributed to residents in villages across Hampshire's picturesque New Forest this month for the first time.

Zara Tindall joins her topless husband Mike in singing video

The granddaughter of the late Queen and her rugby player husband attended a UK festival - believed to be a private party thrown by the Tindalls - over the weekend.

Secret Jeff Bezos and Lauren Sanchez haven’t revealed about wedding

The wedding will be attended by more than 200 A-list guests including Ivanka Trump, Leonardo Di Caprio, Oprah Winfrey and Katie Perry, who are currently arriving for the first party

Tottenham fire back at Man United jibe with Europa League memorabilia

The triumph was the most important of four straight wins over Man United last season, with the defeat also leaving the Red Devils facing a season outside of European competition.
spot_img

Related Articles

Popular Categories

spot_imgspot_img