12.8 C
London
Tuesday, November 17, 2026

Birmingham council was probably never bankrupt, expert says

Birmingham City Council was probably never bankrupt, a group of experts have claimed. 

The Labour-run local authority imposed a wave of swingeing cuts to local services and announced a fire sale of assets after issuing a section 114 notice two years ago, effectively declaring it bankrupt.

But now a group of 35 experts and academics have urged Communities Secretary Steve Reed to launch a public inquiry into the council’s decision – after analysis suggested it had underestimated the funds at its disposal by £1.4 billion. 

Dr James Brackley, of the University of Glasgow, undertook research comparing the figures used by the council to justify the move to subsequent figures in its accounts which were belatedly published in July this year. 

‘These accounts show that the reserves position put forward by the Council at the time of the “bankruptcy” now appears to have been materially incorrect, to such an extent that it now appears that the Council was likely never “bankrupt”,’ the analysis concluded. 

An open letter signed by the experts has called on the Government to investigate ‘how and why such a damaging section 114 notice could have been initiated based on unaudited and, as has now come to light, materially incorrect accounting information’.

It raises yet more embarrassing questions for the crisis-stricken council, which has this year been embroiled in rows for attempting to tear down Union Jacks from lampposts – while leaving Palestine flags in place – and failing to resolve a bin strike. 

The walkout by bin workers at the start of the year resulted in mountains of fetid waste piling up on the pavements across Britain’s second city. 

At the time it declared bankruptcy, the council blamed a combination of ruinous liabilities from equal pay claims, which it said surpassed £760 million, and the fallout from a bungled IT scheme, called Oracle, which had cost £100 million. 

But in their open letter, the group of academics and experts expressed concern that ‘crucial figures’ were  ‘materially misstated’, adding: ‘We are concerned that the issues underlying the Birmingham case could be repeated as other authorities enter into financial difficulty.’

Birmingham City Council imposed a wave of cuts to local services and announced a fire sale of assets after issuing a section 114 notice two years ago, effectively declaring it bankrupt

The analysis found that the general fund of the council in its 2022-24 accounts was around £784 million, as opposed to the £677 million deficit that the council had forecast for its 2023-24 reserves.

This was a result of the council underestimating its reserves, incorrectly omitting other funds and overestimating how much it would face in liabilities from equal pay claims, the analysis concluded. 

The accompanying letter called for an inquiry to ‘learn lessons of the Birmingham case, provide answers to the people of Birmingham, and, crucially, ensure that these lessons inform the upcoming programme of local audit reform’.

Responding to the analysis, the Labour leader of the council, Cllr John Cotton suggested the council’s parlous financial position was partly due to ’14 years of crippling Tory cuts’ that he claimed cost Birmingham more than £1 billion. 

He said: ‘My focus over the last two years has been on dealing with equal pay, the re-implementation of Oracle and with tackling a huge budget deficit. We continue to make progress on all three. 

‘Oracle remains on track, last week we signed an agreement with UNISON and GMB to settle the outstanding equal pay claims brought by the two unions, and crucially, this year we’re on track to deliver a balanced revenue budget without the need for exceptional financial support for the first time in several years.’

The council also said that when the section 114 notice was issued, it was facing a budget shortfall of £87 million and had not yet secured Government approval to cover its equal pay liability through either borrowing or selling off assets. 

The Ministry of Housing, Communities and Local Government (MHCLG) said the decision to issue the notice had been taken locally. 

An spokesman said: ‘Birmingham City Council has made progress on its reform and recovery, but challenges remain, which is why commissioners continue to support the council to deliver for local people.” 

PalestineLabour

Hot this week

Timothee Chalamet matches Kylie Jenner in another cringe look

Just a day after the reality TV star, 28, was pictured in a red latex dress in West Hollywood, the Dune actor, 29, stepped out in an all-red leather look while out in New York on Monday.

Jimmy Kimmel gives sorry excuse for Melania ‘widow’ joke

Jimmy Kimmel joked about Donald Trump and Melania Trump's calls for him to be fired before reacting to the shooting attempt at the White House Correspondents' Dinner.

Woman who married illegal migrant she met in Australia is rescued after he took her to Pakistan, ‘kept her prisoner and beat her every...

French national Sylvie Yasmina, 54, agreed to move to Pakistan with her husband - but claims she was then put through more than a decade of hell.

Trump smiles and fist pumps as he’s greeted by 300 chanting kids

Trump has touched down in Beijing , kicking off a three-day visit marking the first time a sitting US President has visited China in roughly nine years.

Actress said to have sparked Brigitte’s infamous ‘slap’ of Emmanuel

Brigitte Macron's slap of her husband Emmanuel was sparked when she saw a message on his phone from Iranian actress Golshifteh Farahani, a new book has claimed.

‘There is a hijacking. We have taken control of the terrorist – we need help’: Passenger films plea for assistance moments after overpowering knifeman...

The hero who helped subdue the knifeman is seen in footage with blood dripping down his face, emerging from a gash that stretches from his forehead down to his nose.

Dakota Johnson appears to run out of patience and says ‘I’m gonna leave’ as Anne Hathaway takes charge and directs photographers on Verity red...

They've spoken about their close bond saying they had 'great chemistry as friends on the set' of their new movie Verity. 

Katie Holmes, 47, and boyfriend Jason Bard Yarmosky, 39, enjoy another romantic getaway in Lake Como before jetting to Paris Fashion Week

The actress, 47, has been showcasing her romance with the artist, 39, during this year's catwalk season, but flew to the luxurious hotspot for a romantic getaway.

How will the triple lock change from 2030 and what do Andy Burnham’s plans mean for you?

We examine what the state pension is, how it currently works and increases, what is changing and why and how the changes will affect people's finances.

Failed asylum seeker who called for death to Jews and praised Hamas is moved by police after he was found living in taxpayer-funded semi

Palestinian migrant Abu Wadee, 34, served nine months in prison after he was exposed by the Mail on Sunday as arriving in the UK in a small boat in March 2025.

Giggling Kate delights elderly minibus passengers as she joins volunteers community group that helps pensioners enjoy their independence

Catherine arrived in picturesque Pulborough to join the team at the West Sussex Minibus, which acts as a vital lifeline for people who cannot easily access public transport.

Tom Cruise fawns over ‘stunning’ Kate Middleton and says the future king made a ‘smart choice’ marrying her because she is ‘intelligent, charismatic and...

Tom Cruise couldn't hide his delight over his recent meeting with Kate Middleton as he gushed over the 'stunning' Princess Of Wales in a new interview.

How will the triple lock change from 2030 and what do Andy Burnham’s plans mean for you?

We examine what the state pension is, how it currently works and increases, what is changing and why and how the changes will affect people's finances.
spot_img

Related Articles

Popular Categories

spot_imgspot_img