There is only one course open to the Tories. The polls show them in third place by vote share and, incredibly, in fifth place by seat projection.
The electorate has not forgiven the mistakes of the last government. What, then, can they do?
They must be the adults in the room: the party of order and discipline, the party of living within our means, the party prepared to make unpopular decisions for the long-term good of the economy.
Will that win them the next election? Maybe not. But it will at least keep them viable in the event that a future Reform government goes the way of all populist parties and disappoints its supporters.
Opening the Conservative conference yesterday, Kemi Badenoch committed her party to withdrawing from the European Convention on Human Rights (ECHR). What was telling was not so much the policy as the serious tone in which it was presented, the preparation that had gone into it, the way in which she anticipated possible problems with implementation.
To say, ‘Let’s quit the ECHR’ is easy. We’re all fed up with judges overturning deportation orders on grounds that some foreign criminal might not get the right healthcare in his country of origin.
But Badenoch was doing much more than making promises. She had asked her Shadow Attorney General, Lord Wolfson, a serious and highly regarded KC, to look at what needed to change for Britain to be able to enforce repatriation orders. Lord Wolfson, who was not personally against ECHR membership, heard evidence over several months, considering all the possible snags.
What would withdrawal mean for the Good Friday Agreement? For the Windsor Framework (the post-Brexit legal agreement between the UK and EU)? For our Trade and Cooperation Agreement with the EU? What other treaties might need to change?
What about domestic statutes, such as the Human Rights Act? What about the way immigration tribunals work? What about the wider context of judicial review – that is, the right of judges to look at political decisions?
Lord Wolfson looked at these things thoroughly, with the result that the Tories have a robust and roadworthy policy.
Will it make a difference with voters? I doubt it. Few people, other than political anoraks, are interested in process. Slogans trump substance. Still, it is the right thing to do.
It was, after all, Britain’s fondness for slogans over substance that got us into this mess. Sir Keir Starmer keeps promising to deport illegals, but the numbers carry on rising. David Cameron had the same problem.
Nigel Farage has not yet had the chance to let us down. But not even his keenest supporters claim that detailed policy is his strong suit. During a recent TV documentary, he was asked how he planned to remove all illegals from Britain when there might be as many as 2 million, and when no other country had ever managed such a thing.
‘It’s an aspiration,’ he replied cheerfully. When the interviewer said that Reform voters might be expecting more than an aspiration, Farage opined that all policy commitments were aspirations.
My guess is that Reform’s style – airy and broad-brush, but also angry and indignant – is going down better than the Tories’ nerdy obsession with legal changes. For now.
Still, some voters do care about the feasibility of manifesto promises. They may, at present, be fewer than 50 per cent; but they are more than 17 per cent, which is where the Conservatives are polling.
What goes for immigration goes for economics. Labour came to office thinking there was a lever marked ‘growth’ that the Tories had for some reason refused to pull.
In fact, our economy is weak because we keep voting to weaken it. We demand generous welfare payments, the pensions triple lock, paid sick leave, the right to work from home, a state monopoly in healthcare. Undoing these things would be unpopular, but would deliver growth.
Labour has shown it is incapable of marginally slowing the rise in benefits spending, let alone reversing it.
Reform baulks at saying unpopular things. It backs the triple lock and wants to lift the cap on child benefit, while at the same time promising huge tax cuts.
Again, I suspect it is capturing the popular mood better than the Tories, with their unexciting insistence on balancing the books.
The question is whether that mood will last when the collapse comes. It may happen under a future Reform government, though my guess is that it will happen sooner, under Labour.
When it is clear the money has run out, that our quangogracy and administrative state have led us to ruin and we need a thorough overhaul of how we are governed, there will be a demand for a party with a plan.
Argentina needed to touch bottom before it turned to the radical libertarian Javier Milei. Britain itself needed to go through the trauma of the IMF bailout and the Winter of Discontent before it was ready for Margaret Thatcher.
From Badenoch’s point of view, this will seem unattractive. Must she wait for a crash before people are willing to listen to her?
Not exactly. ‘Wait’ is the wrong word. If they want to be heard when the time comes, the Tories need to put the work in now, explaining what the problem is – we are spending beyond our means, and we are run by unaccountable judges and bureaucrats – and setting out their solutions.
It will be unrewarding work. They will get scant recognition. The polls will barely flicker.
But, unless they do it, they have no chance of recovering.
There is, of course, another risk. By setting out their detailed plans on immigration and deportations now, they invite Reform to filch them. To which the proper response is surely: ‘Good’. If Reform acquires serious and deliverable policies, so much the better for Britain.
Which brings us to the final paradox. The Tories and Reform are very likely to be contesting the next election on near-identical manifestoes. The two parties may appeal to different electorates, both geographically and socio-economically; they may have a very different vibe; but they are closer on policy than either likes to admit.
The best way to bring Britain back to secure borders and growth would be for the two Rightist parties to agree not to field candidates in seats they could not win – the prospect that stalks Labour’s nightmares.
Reform activists loathe the idea, but I sense that Farage is more realistic. He spoke at his party conference of lack of government experience being his biggest weakness, and he knows how hard it is to find hundreds of qualified parliamentary candidates.
Above all, he knows that, in order to make the required structural changes, he needs a mandate rather than just a majority. Being elected, Starmer-like, with 34 per cent of the vote would be a weak position to take on the entire administrative state.
Is this, then, what the Tories are reduced to? Being the sensible, pro-business party that appeals to a non-populist constituency so as to be the junior coalition partner in an eventual Reform coalition?
There would be no dishonour in that. But the likelier outcome is that Reform wins on its own and then fails to make the unpopular decisions that would bring our budget back into balance. At that stage, there will surely be a market for a party offering economic seriousness.
A plan for victory at the election after next, then? For a party that has existed for three-and-a-half centuries, that is surely an eyeblink.
Lord Hannan of Kingsclere is president of the Institute for Free Trade


