Young Sherlock (Amazon Prime Video)
There’s no shortage of Sherlocks. Since the character’s creation, 140 years ago, we’ve seen the Great Detective in every possible guise – brilliant, bumbling, gay, grumpy, modern, and even (thanks to Disney) a mouse.
He’s been played by all sorts of improbables, from Robert Downey Jr (Sherlock as an all-action hero) to Ian McKellen (Holmes aged 93). He’s even been a complete idiot, in versions starring Michael Caine or Peter Cook.
It seems a bit of a cheek, then, for Amazon Prime to release yet another incarnation under their ‘Originals’ banner. This time, he’s Young Sherlock, but of course that’s been done before too, by ITV in 1982 (starring Guy Henry) and for the cinema a few years later, with Holmes and Watson at boarding school.
But Amazon boss Jeff Bezos expects a new twist for his billions. So here it is: 19-year-old Holmes (Hero Fiennes Tiffin) is both young and a complete idiot. And the witless script is an insult to viewers with even the lowest expectations.
How’s that for ‘Original’?
Only an enormous amount of money could make a Sherlock as shh… amelessly awful as this. Amazon begins by stripping him of all the traits that make him unique. Instead of being scintillating, he’s a bit of a plodder, somewhat slow on the uptake.
He makes gormless, cliched jokes: ‘Upstairs for thinking, downstairs for dancing,’ he tells his best chum James Moriarty (Donal Finn). He’s got an eye for the girls. He’s a heavy drinker, but he doesn’t smoke. He wears a pin-striped blazer, like Bertie Wooster on a picnic, but never a cape or deerstalker.
Worst of all, far from being aloof and superior, he’s a smarmy, shallow charmer, desperate to be everyone’s temporary friend. Remember Lib Dem leader Nick Clegg? Imagine him as a teenager and that’s Young Sherlock.
One detail from Arthur Conan Doyle’s stories has been retained: he does have an older brother, Mycroft (Max Irons), who is Something Important In Government.
The rest of the Holmes family has never forgiven Sherlock for an incident when, aged nine, he refused to play with his little sister, who went off and drowned herself instead. Mycroft does his best for the young man, announcing, ‘I’ve secured you a place at Oxford – arguably the greatest university in the world.’
But guess what? He’s to be a college servant, not a student. Isn’t that Original?
Mycroft hasn’t thought through his wheeze. It turns out to be embarrassing to have a younger brother below stairs, especially when ‘the Man Who Invented The British Empire’ (Colin Firth) discovers the connection.
By then, Sherlock has been seduced by a Chinese Princess who has lost some ancient scrolls – stolen from her, despite her ability to fight off gangs of robbers with slo-mo kung fu moves.
That whirring sound you can hear is Conan Doyle spinning like a propeller in his grave.


