6.2 C
London
Thursday, November 19, 2026

Soft-touch asylum judge who sides with rapists is mocking all of us

A Gazan family of six granted the right to settle in Britain under a scheme intended for Ukrainians. 

A convicted rapist who avoided deportation to Afghanistan on the basis that the authorities there might take a ‘dim view’ of sex offenders. 

A murderer blocked from deportation to his native Bangladesh because he claimed he was bisexual.

They might sound like a random selection of the increasingly bizarre legal cases to be heard in Britain under the European Convention on Human Rights (ECHR). 

But they all have one thing in common: one of the judges sitting on each of the cases was Hugo Norton-Taylor.

It is six years since Norton-Taylor, then 46, was appointed a salaried judge in the Upper Tribunal, Immigration and Asylum chamber – the court to which failed asylum-seekers and other foreign nationals eager to remain in Britain can apply to have their cases reconsidered.

But, in that time, Norton-Taylor has acquired something of a reputation. In a judiciary that sometimes seems dominated by bleeding-heart liberals, he stands out as having an unusually large number of unfathomable rulings to his name.

Hugo Norton-Taylor is a judge in the Upper Tribunal, Immigration and Asylum chamber – the court to which failed asylum-seekers and other foreign nationals eager to remain in Britain can apply to have their cases reconsidered

It takes something for both Keir Starmer, himself a human rights lawyer, and our Left-wing Foreign Secretary David Lammy to be shocked by a decision made under the ECHR. 

But that is what has happened in the case of a Gazan family who applied for asylum in the UK through the Ukrainian resettlement scheme.

The family – not unreasonably – lost their case in the Lower Tribunal on the grounds that they were not Ukrainian citizens and had no connection to the country.

Yet, in January this year, the decision was overturned by Norton-Taylor, who ruled that the earlier decision did not ‘strike a fair balance between the appellants’ interests and those of the public’.

Norton-Taylor was still trying to defend this ruling last week when he was involved in a public spat with Lammy.

The family, as it happens, have not yet made it to Britain because they are in Gaza and need permission from the Israeli government to leave. 

Lammy has so far refused to grant the consular support from the UK, which would be needed to facilitate their journey to Britain – prompting Norton-Taylor to urge him to ‘think again’.

It takes something for both Keir Starmer, himself a human rights lawyer, and our Left-wing Foreign Secretary David Lammy to be shocked by a decision made under the European Convention on Human Rights (ECHR)

As the Foreign Office has pointed out with some alarm, Norton-Taylor’s decision may open the door for anyone living in a conflict zone anywhere in the world to apply for asylum in the UK. That could be millions of people. 

Yet, unlike government ministers, the judiciary does not have to deal with the practical and financial consequences of its rulings.

Norton-Taylor happens to be the son of Richard Norton-Taylor, a former Guardian journalist who now writes for online publication DeclassifiedUK, often on Palestinian issues.

In one recent offering, Norton-Taylor Sr argued, somewhat hysterically, that the Government’s decision to proscribe the group Palestine Action after its activists broke into RAF Brize Norton and spray-painted two aircraft ‘threatens all our civil liberties’. 

Perhaps he would like to name a single country in the world that would tolerate protesters breaking into its military bases and vandalising equipment.

I don’t know what the younger Norton-Taylor thinks about the Government’s decision to ban Palestine Action. But when it comes to his general liberal sympathies, he certainly appears to be a chip off the old block.

Norton-Taylor seems to a chip of the old block. His father, a journalist who writes for online publication DeclassifiedUK, argued, that the Government’s decision to proscribe the group Palestine Action after its activists broke into RAF Brize Norton and spray-painted two aircraft (pictured) ‘threatens all our civil liberties’

In the same month as his eccentric ruling granted asylum to the Palestinian family, it emerged that he had also handed Ramazan Morina, an Albanian who had twice been refused asylum, the right to remain in Britain on the grounds that it would be ‘harsh’ on his stepchildren. 

Never mind enforcing migration law, nor acknowledging that Albania is a safe country, in Norton-Taylor’s hands our immigration system hinges on the feelings of children who aren’t even descended from the asylum seeker in question.

Even more outrageous, to my mind, was a ruling in 2022 to block the deportation of Afghan native Ibrahim Ahmadi, who had been granted asylum before being jailed for seven years for raping a woman in Glasgow.

Serious offenders are supposed to be removed from Britain on release from prison. But Norton-Taylor, sitting with another judge, Tom Wilding, ruled that Ahmadi couldn’t be sent home because it was ‘reasonably likely that the Taliban would take a dim view of an individual who had committed a violent sexual offence in a Western country’.

Given how the Taliban treat women, it is hard to see that they would be terribly bothered by what he had done, but yet again, thanks to judges such as Norton-Taylor, we have ended up with a migration system that rewards murderers and rapists for their crimes.

Ahmadi, by the way, was helped in his appeal by £1,330 worth of legal aid – paid for by you and me.

It was a similar story with ‘EH’, a Bangladeshi who had been jailed for a minimum of 12 years in 2008 for murdering his wife. The killer had claimed he was ‘bisexual’ – although the court accepted that he had lied about this to support his case.

On his release, EH should have been summarily deported, but this was blocked on the grounds of Article 3 of the ECHR which provides protection against degrading and inhumane treatment, such as the type he may have faced for his fictitious ‘bisexuality’.

The judge involved? You’ve guessed it: Norton-Taylor again.

Decisions such as these are surely a long way from what the bureaucrats who drafted the ECHR had in mind back in 1950.

But the problem with the convention – as its critics have rightly highlighted – is that its vague principles are open to wide interpretation. That gives judges huge leeway in their rulings – which certain liberal-minded officials are only too happy to take advantage of. And that’s only scratching the surface.

Let’s not forget Shaban Binaku, the Kosovan who illegally re-entered Britain after being convicted of theft, possessing a weapon and supplying class A drugs – but was granted permission to stay in 2020 on the grounds that deportation would be unfair on his children.

Aghan native Ibrahim Ahmadi was granted asylum before being jailed for seven years for raping a woman in Glasgow. Norton-Taylor, sitting with Judge Tom Wilding, blocked his deportation

Or the Sudanese ‘16-year-old’ who was ruled more ‘likely than not’ to be telling the truth about his age when he applied for asylum – despite his receding hairline, beard and physical assessments suggesting he was closer to 25. Once again, rulings with Norton-Taylor’s fingerprints all over them.

He is not be the only judge making decisions that seem remarkably favourable to migrants. But it is astonishing how many times he is involved in overruling ‘harsher’ decisions made in the Lower Tribunal.

More concerning than these, however, is the ‘groupthink’ of other judges to try to prevent any criticism. In February – when both the Prime Minister and Conservative leader Kemi Badenoch condemned the ruling to grant asylum to the Gazan family – Baroness Carr, Lady Chief Justice, complained about a ‘mounting campaign of attacks’ on judges.

In a democracy, it is vital that we have the right to hold those in power to account. When judges such as Norton-Taylor are effectively imposing a migration policy that is vastly at odds with public opinion and stated government policy, that matters.

For many of us, most of Norton-Taylor’s rulings stink. Hopelessly soft-touch judges like him are undermining public confidence in our appeals courts, perhaps irreparably.

Afghanistan

Hot this week

Timothee Chalamet matches Kylie Jenner in another cringe look

Just a day after the reality TV star, 28, was pictured in a red latex dress in West Hollywood, the Dune actor, 29, stepped out in an all-red leather look while out in New York on Monday.

Jimmy Kimmel gives sorry excuse for Melania ‘widow’ joke

Jimmy Kimmel joked about Donald Trump and Melania Trump's calls for him to be fired before reacting to the shooting attempt at the White House Correspondents' Dinner.

Woman who married illegal migrant she met in Australia is rescued after he took her to Pakistan, ‘kept her prisoner and beat her every...

French national Sylvie Yasmina, 54, agreed to move to Pakistan with her husband - but claims she was then put through more than a decade of hell.

Trump smiles and fist pumps as he’s greeted by 300 chanting kids

Trump has touched down in Beijing , kicking off a three-day visit marking the first time a sitting US President has visited China in roughly nine years.

Actress said to have sparked Brigitte’s infamous ‘slap’ of Emmanuel

Brigitte Macron's slap of her husband Emmanuel was sparked when she saw a message on his phone from Iranian actress Golshifteh Farahani, a new book has claimed.

‘There is a hijacking. We have taken control of the terrorist – we need help’: Passenger films plea for assistance moments after overpowering knifeman...

The hero who helped subdue the knifeman is seen in footage with blood dripping down his face, emerging from a gash that stretches from his forehead down to his nose.

Dakota Johnson appears to run out of patience and says ‘I’m gonna leave’ as Anne Hathaway takes charge and directs photographers on Verity red...

They've spoken about their close bond saying they had 'great chemistry as friends on the set' of their new movie Verity. 

Katie Holmes, 47, and boyfriend Jason Bard Yarmosky, 39, enjoy another romantic getaway in Lake Como before jetting to Paris Fashion Week

The actress, 47, has been showcasing her romance with the artist, 39, during this year's catwalk season, but flew to the luxurious hotspot for a romantic getaway.

How will the triple lock change from 2030 and what do Andy Burnham’s plans mean for you?

We examine what the state pension is, how it currently works and increases, what is changing and why and how the changes will affect people's finances.

Failed asylum seeker who called for death to Jews and praised Hamas is moved by police after he was found living in taxpayer-funded semi

Palestinian migrant Abu Wadee, 34, served nine months in prison after he was exposed by the Mail on Sunday as arriving in the UK in a small boat in March 2025.

Giggling Kate delights elderly minibus passengers as she joins volunteers community group that helps pensioners enjoy their independence

Catherine arrived in picturesque Pulborough to join the team at the West Sussex Minibus, which acts as a vital lifeline for people who cannot easily access public transport.

Tom Cruise fawns over ‘stunning’ Kate Middleton and says the future king made a ‘smart choice’ marrying her because she is ‘intelligent, charismatic and...

Tom Cruise couldn't hide his delight over his recent meeting with Kate Middleton as he gushed over the 'stunning' Princess Of Wales in a new interview.

How will the triple lock change from 2030 and what do Andy Burnham’s plans mean for you?

We examine what the state pension is, how it currently works and increases, what is changing and why and how the changes will affect people's finances.
spot_img

Related Articles

Popular Categories

spot_imgspot_img