6.2 C
London
Thursday, November 19, 2026

David Lammy’s ‘soft justice’ reform of jury trial is backed by MPS

David Lammy’s ‘soft justice’ reforms of jury trials have been supported by MPs who voted by a majority of 101 to pass the bill at its first Commons hurdle. 

Tonight’s decision to back the controversial Courts and Tribunals Bill comes despite a Labour MP condemning the curbs in an emotional speech about being raped.

Charlotte Nichols said that the attack, which occurred while she was an MP, had caused PTSD and led her to being sectioned for her own protection.

She accused the Justice Secretary of ‘weaponising’ the experiences of rape victims to justify changes ‘that aren’t directly relevant to them’.

A significant number of Labour MPs abstained from voting for the Bill on Tuesday night after many raised objections.

Around 90 Labour MPs had no vote recorded, suggesting a considerable amount of dissent and raising questions about whether it will become law.

Ten Labour MPs voted against, however 301 voted in favour, allowing it to pass its first Commons hurdle.

Seven Labour MPs, including former shadow chancellor John McDonnell, also voted in favour of a Conservative amendment to reject the Bill. The amendment was defeated.

Labour MP Charlotte Nichols talked about her experience during a debate on the jury trials legislation in the House of Commons

The Tories said: ‘Keir Starmer and David Lammy should hang their heads in shame. They have struck the first blow against our ancient legal right to trial by jury.

‘And it is clear that their party has serious misgivings about the Bill. Some MPs chose to vote against their Government, and some chose to abstain.’

The controversial Courts and Tribunals Bill will remove jury trials for cases with a likely sentence of under three years to tackle the court backlog.

Ahead of the Commons vote, Mr Lammy, who is also Deputy Prime Minister, faced a furious backlash to his plans.

Addressing MPs, he acknowledged that the changes had provoked ‘fierce’ debate but said it would reduce trial times and free up hearing days.

He said that if no action was taken, the backlog could reach 200,000 cases in a decade and pointed to research which said it would reduce trial times by at least 20 per cent.

‘The choice before the House is stark. We cannot continue with this rising backlog,’ he said.

‘Victims are currently worn down, people simply give up, cases collapse and offenders remain free. Free to roam the streets, free to commit more crimes, free to create more victims.’

But Ms Nichols accused the Government of not helping rape victims as she waived her right to anonymity to reveal that she was attacked.

She revealed she had waited 1,088 days for the trial as she criticised the court backlog for exacerbating her experience.

Join the debate

Should the right to trial by jury ever be limited?

Comment now

Deputy Prime Minister and Justice Secretary David Lammy delivers a keynote speech on reforming the justice system last month

She accused the Government of pitting survivors and defendants against each other in a ‘deeply damaging’ way.

‘Don’t say that this bill helps deliver justice for rape victims until it actually materially does,’ she told Mr Lammy.

Ms Nichols added: ‘There is so much that we can be doing for rape victims that isn’t the Lord Chancellor using them as a cudgel to drive through reforms that aren’t directly relevant to them.

‘In this debate, experiences like mine feel like they’ve been weaponised and are being used for rhetorical misdirection.’

Meanwhile, rebel ringleader Mr Turner said the Government’s proposed changes to juries were ‘unworkable, unjust, unpopular and unnecessary’.

However, the former barrister said he would abstain because he was confident these measures would not become law.

‘I am more confident now than ever I was that the worst parts of this Bill will be defeated at amendment stage,’ he said.

He added that under the proposed legislation, not one of those 900 sub-postmasters in the Horizon scandal who were convicted would have been entitled to a trial before their peers.

It came after former sub-postmaster Jo Hamilton who was wrongly convicted in the scandal wrote to Mr Lammy urging him not to ditch the ‘safety net of a jury’.

Labour MP Stella Creasy suggested she could not support the Bill as she did not believe magistrates’ courts have capacity for cases that will no longer be heard by crown courts.

Labour MP Jon Trickett also branded the plan to curtail access to jury trials ‘oppressive’ and ‘authoritarian’.

He said that jury trials are ‘a fundamental part of our constitutional system and the idea somehow that we should begin to abandon it is a mistaken one’.

He added: ‘I am not convinced. This is oppressive, it’s authoritarian and quite honestly, Deputy Prime Minister, as much I admire, it’s reactionary, too.’

Shadow justice secretary Nick Timothy said the Government was attacking ‘an ancient English right’ which made the UK legal system ‘the envy of the world’.

He said the Government was ‘rushing’ proposed changes to jury trial through Parliament ‘at breakneck speed’.

Father of the House Sir Edward Leigh said the court backlog was a ‘temporary administrative crisis’ which should not be used to justify the jury trials changes.

Meanwhile, victims’ minister Jess Phillips said she was a victim of the courts backlog with a man accused of breaching a restraining order against her not due in crown court until 2028.

Under the Courts and Tribunals Bill, cases with a likely sentence of three years or less will only be heard by a single crown court judge, without a jury, in the biggest shake-up of the criminal justice system for 800 years.

Magistrates’ powers will be increased so they can hand down sentences of up to 18 months’ imprisonment, up from 12 months currently, so they will be able to deal with more cases.

The proposed changes follow recommendations from a review by retired Court of Appeal judge Sir Brian Leveson published last year.

The Commons vote came after thousands of lawyers signed a letter accusing Mr Lammy of seeking to erode a ‘deeply entrenched constitutional principle for negligible gain and with substantial risks’.

The letter was organised by the Bar Council and signed by top lawyers, including the former director of public prosecutions Sir David Calvert-Smith.

It said that ‘chronic underfunding’ was to blame for the backlog, adding: ‘Juries have not caused this crisis. Practically, the proposals are based on little evidence.’

The controversial court reforms passed their first Commons hurdle, with 304 MPs voting in favour to 203 voting against, giving a majority of 101.

LabourDavid Lammy

Hot this week

Timothee Chalamet matches Kylie Jenner in another cringe look

Just a day after the reality TV star, 28, was pictured in a red latex dress in West Hollywood, the Dune actor, 29, stepped out in an all-red leather look while out in New York on Monday.

Jimmy Kimmel gives sorry excuse for Melania ‘widow’ joke

Jimmy Kimmel joked about Donald Trump and Melania Trump's calls for him to be fired before reacting to the shooting attempt at the White House Correspondents' Dinner.

Woman who married illegal migrant she met in Australia is rescued after he took her to Pakistan, ‘kept her prisoner and beat her every...

French national Sylvie Yasmina, 54, agreed to move to Pakistan with her husband - but claims she was then put through more than a decade of hell.

Trump smiles and fist pumps as he’s greeted by 300 chanting kids

Trump has touched down in Beijing , kicking off a three-day visit marking the first time a sitting US President has visited China in roughly nine years.

Actress said to have sparked Brigitte’s infamous ‘slap’ of Emmanuel

Brigitte Macron's slap of her husband Emmanuel was sparked when she saw a message on his phone from Iranian actress Golshifteh Farahani, a new book has claimed.

‘There is a hijacking. We have taken control of the terrorist – we need help’: Passenger films plea for assistance moments after overpowering knifeman...

The hero who helped subdue the knifeman is seen in footage with blood dripping down his face, emerging from a gash that stretches from his forehead down to his nose.

Dakota Johnson appears to run out of patience and says ‘I’m gonna leave’ as Anne Hathaway takes charge and directs photographers on Verity red...

They've spoken about their close bond saying they had 'great chemistry as friends on the set' of their new movie Verity. 

Katie Holmes, 47, and boyfriend Jason Bard Yarmosky, 39, enjoy another romantic getaway in Lake Como before jetting to Paris Fashion Week

The actress, 47, has been showcasing her romance with the artist, 39, during this year's catwalk season, but flew to the luxurious hotspot for a romantic getaway.

How will the triple lock change from 2030 and what do Andy Burnham’s plans mean for you?

We examine what the state pension is, how it currently works and increases, what is changing and why and how the changes will affect people's finances.

Failed asylum seeker who called for death to Jews and praised Hamas is moved by police after he was found living in taxpayer-funded semi

Palestinian migrant Abu Wadee, 34, served nine months in prison after he was exposed by the Mail on Sunday as arriving in the UK in a small boat in March 2025.

Giggling Kate delights elderly minibus passengers as she joins volunteers community group that helps pensioners enjoy their independence

Catherine arrived in picturesque Pulborough to join the team at the West Sussex Minibus, which acts as a vital lifeline for people who cannot easily access public transport.

Tom Cruise fawns over ‘stunning’ Kate Middleton and says the future king made a ‘smart choice’ marrying her because she is ‘intelligent, charismatic and...

Tom Cruise couldn't hide his delight over his recent meeting with Kate Middleton as he gushed over the 'stunning' Princess Of Wales in a new interview.

How will the triple lock change from 2030 and what do Andy Burnham’s plans mean for you?

We examine what the state pension is, how it currently works and increases, what is changing and why and how the changes will affect people's finances.
spot_img

Related Articles

Popular Categories

spot_imgspot_img