8.8 C
London
Thursday, May 7, 2026

Why stricter security on trains is ‘almost impossible’

After Saturday evening’s mass stabbing onboard a train travelling from Doncaster to London, rail services have seen increased security.

Transport Secretary Heidi Alexander promised more visible police patrols at mainline stations over the following days.

In order to reassure passengers, officers would be present across key stations in the UK.

She said: ‘I do understand that people will want to feel reassured following what happened.

‘Thankfully incidents like this on the public transport network are very, very rare.’

She added: ‘We are investing in improved CCTV in stations and the Home Office will soon be launching a consultation on more facial recognition technology which could be deployed in stations as well.’

Fears have grown around the potential need for more security on trains in the long term, however stricter enforcement could be difficult for rail services. 

Earlier this week, the Transport Secretary criticised the possibility of implementing ‘airport-style’ scanners at train stations.

After Saturday evening's mass stabbing onboard a train travelling from Doncaster to London, rail services have seen increased security

Fears have grown around the potential need for more security on trains in the long term, however stricter enforcement could be difficult for rail services

She said metal-detector scanners at train stations would ‘make life impossible’ for passengers.

Ms Alexander has reassured passengers of the safety of trains, saying: ‘Our trains are some of the most safest forms of public transport anywhere in the world. For every one million passenger journeys that are made, there are 27 crimes.’ 

With the exception of London St Pancras International, no UK station has airport-style security.

It has been argued implementing stricter security on trains would be extremely difficult, and labelled ‘virtually impossible’ by travel correspondent Simon Calder.

He wrote in The Independent: ‘There is not the space, the money nor the willingness to search passengers on UK domestic trains prior to boarding. So why not get more staff on board?’

He added that the stabbing took place on an intercity train with onboard crew. 

Simon explained: ‘In a perfect world, a British Transport Police officer would patrol every train. Better still: one in every carriage. 

‘But financially that would be ruinous. The railways currently cost the taxpayer £400 per second in subsidy. Agreed, having greater reassurance about safety would encourage more people to travel by train.

It has been argued implementing stricter security on trains would be extremely difficult

‘But with the Department for Transport (DfT) facing cuts in this month’s budget, increasing spending on security simply isn’t in prospect.’

He also added trains are very safe, and the death toll of rail passengers is extremely low. 

This is notable especially in comparison to flight safety, as planes can be particularly vulnerable to incidents such as hijacking.

According to date from the Office of Rail and Road, there were just 14 non-workforce fatalities (passenger or public) in the year April 2024 to March 2025.

The Home Office

Hot this week

Diana’s ex-hairdresser condemns ‘evil’ comments about Kate’s hair

Princess Diana's former hairdresser has condemned 'nasty' comments made about the Princess of Wales 's hair - as she stepped out with her newly blonde tresses.

The unusual breakfast request Princess Lilibet asks Meghan Markle for

Meghan Markle revealed her children's favourite meals and that she 'doesn't like baking' on the second season of her lifestyle show With Love, Meghan.

Experts reveal how many tins of tuna is safe to eat a week

The NHS advises people to eat at least two portions of fish a week, yet a recent investigation revealed toxic metals, including mercury, could be lurking in cans of tinned tuna sold in the UK.

Some people DO see ghosts – and medics say there’s an explanation

An astonishing third of people in the UK and almost half of Americans say they believe in ghosts, spirits and other types of paranormal activity.

Prince Philip’s nickname only his nearest and dearest could call him

From 'Lillibet' to 'Grandpa Wales', members of the Royal Family are known to go by many nicknames.

The Neighbourhood pulled from primetime slot after poor ratings

The new programme, which was announced to great fanfare, was set to launch Norton on the channel and rival the BBC 's popular The Traitors .

Meghan shares unseen photo of Archie asleep on Harry’s chest as a baby

The Duchess of Sussex took to Instagram to post a pair of unseen photos of Archie, one of the young prince lying on his father's chest and the other of him pictured with his little sister Princess Lilibet.

Dog steals the show at King’s garden party – getting pats from royals

Vegas, two, a Hearing Dog for the Deaf managed to jump up at three senior royals - Their Majesties and the Princess Royal.

The four powerful women who won’t let Meghan fail: DOMINIQUE HINES

Meghan Markle is out. Out of the Met Gala. Out of favour in Hollywood. Out of momentum. That, at least, is the current narrative. But the reality is rather different.

If Arsenal win two trophies, is this team better than the Invincibles?

We want to hear from you after an epic night for Arsenal in Europe and what could be a truly historic and memorable campaign for Mikel Arteta's side.

Truth about Love Luxury. Insiders tell MOLLY CLAYTON what’s going on

In recent months, the brand has become infamous - not for its high-end wares, but for its unusual social media output. All of Love Luxury's videos, play perfectly for a social media audience.

Starmer’s future hangs in the balance as millions head to the polls

Millions of voters across England, Scotland and Wales will head to the polls for what opposition leaders have branded a referendum on the Prime Minister's record.

Still thinking of going Green today? A list of their daft policies…

If you are still thinking of voting for the Green Party when heading to the polls today, make sure to take a look at the policies they intend to bring in.
spot_img

Related Articles

Popular Categories

spot_imgspot_img